Pages

Monday, October 01, 2007

'Sharia is Often Perceived as Oppressive and Brutal by Westerners'

The BCC is doing their part to get the Brits ready for Sharia Law, as they give viewers an inside look at how a Sharia Court works in Nigeria.

I hope they're paying attention. It isn't pretty.

Inside a Sharia Court
A devout Muslim, Judge Isah explains that Sharia is "a path which leads to Almighty Allah, so you cannot separate Sharia from Islam and Islam from Sharia".

Over the weeks I spent at his court, I witnessed the man's passion, his conviction, his wry humour, and the speed with which he administered his justice. And I was astonished by the extraordinary variety of cases he sees each week.
Nothing like the "wry humour" of a sharia judge. Must be a real cut-up between handing out stonings and public floggings.
In one case, Sa'adiyya Ibrahim claimed that since her separation from her husband, he had refused to perform his Islamic duty of providing for her. He insisted he had.

In the end, the judge decided in her favour because she swore it was true on a copy of the Koran. Judge Isah - which literally means Jesus - was convinced the plaintiff would not risk divine condemnation by making a false oath. He ordered the husband to pay up, which he did without protest.
For all anyone knows, she's a pathological liar, but hey, she swore on a Koran, so who are we to question her?
His court works more like a community centre, where every morning he sees people in his chambers. His aim is to mediate and avoid unnecessary expensive court cases that clog up the system.

This plays an important role in more way than one. Sharia is attractive to local people because anyone can bring a case to court and represent themselves.

"In our Sharia law, we can summon anyone to appear provided there is an allegation to defend. No exceptions," explained Judge Isah.
Boy, Rush Limbaugh would be in court every day. No wonder the left is so fervently embracing dhimmitude.
Sharia is often perceived as oppressive and brutal by Westerners, because of punishments like stoning to death for adultery and amputations for theft.
Uh, yes, I do perceive stoning for adultery and amputations for theft as oppressive and brutal, as do most normal human beings. Because such stone-age punishments are, well, oppressive and brutal.
One hot, dusty afternoon, I followed three young men being taken from the courtroom to the market square. They were convicted of alcoholism - strictly frowned upon in Muslim society - and received 80 lashes in front of a gathered crowd.

Judge Isah explained that public humiliation was part of the punishment. It also served to deter others who were tempted to indulge in vice.

"By stopping people from drinking alcohol, society will be in harmony and sanity," he said. "More over the sentence of 80 lashes is in the Koran so no one can question it".
See how simple it all is. It's it the Koran, so do not question it.

Is seething and whining also ordered up by the Koran when a Muslim perceives an offense?
In Zamfara, there are only two recorded cases of people who have had their hands amputated for stealing. According to official records both of them refused their right of appeal and insisted the punishment be carried out.

I found one amputee, Lawalli Isah, still languishing in the local prison, but when questioned about the severity of the punishment, he simply said: "It is in my religion, I accept it".
Like he's going to complain?
Most of the people that I met in Zamfara said they welcomed Sharia. It has cut down drinking and violence, and the court is no longer an intimidating place of wigs and gowns, doing business in a language that they do not understand.

After six weeks in Zamfara, I can see how Judge Isah's court functions well as a small claims court for this rural Islamic society. But my reservations about Sharia remain the same. For me, the sticking points are still the floggings and the amputations, and the undeniably unfair treatment of women in rape and adultery cases.
Other than that, it's just peachy.

UPDATE: LGF has the video here.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.