Porkulus: The $800 Billion Mistake Includes $600 Million For New Government Vehicles

No doubt you'll also be picking up the tab for all the free gas.

As a conservative economist, I might be expected to oppose a stimulus plan. In fact, I've declared my support for a stimulus. But the fiscal package now before Congress needs to be thoroughly revised. In its current form, it does too little to raise national spending and employment. It would be better for the Senate to delay legislation for a month, or even two, if that's what it takes to produce a much better bill. We cannot afford an $800 billion mistake.

Start with the tax side. The plan is to give a tax cut of $500 a year for two years to each employed person. That's not a good way to increase consumer spending. Experience shows that the money from such temporary, lump-sum tax cuts is largely saved or used to pay down debt. Only about 15 percent of last year's tax rebates led to additional spending.

The proposed business tax cuts are also likely to do little to increase business investment and employment. The extended loss "carrybacks" are primarily lump-sum payments to selected companies. The bonus depreciation plan would do little to raise capital spending in the current environment of weak demand because the tax benefits in the early years would be recaptured later.

Instead, the tax changes should focus on providing incentives to households and businesses to increase current spending. Why not a temporary refundable tax credit to households that purchase cars or other major consumer durables, analogous to the investment tax credit for businesses? Or a temporary tax credit for home improvements? In that way, the same total tax reduction could produce much more spending and employment.

You'll never see any tax cuts from this crew because it would demolish their class warfare argument. Admitting you're wrong can never happen for liberals.

Click on the images at the link to see precisely where your money is going.

And with that news, we present Suitably Flip's Stimulus, Illustrated-Part II. Click the image to enlarge.